Dr. Pierre Chang's missing left arm

[ThisIsMyDestiny]

ah i bought the boxset last week, it's already on the shelves in England

i watched He's Our You last night, and when Oldham gives Sayid the truth serum he names The Swan as one of their stations, to which Radzinsky replies ''how can he know what we were gonna call it? we haven't even built it yet!'' so that's pretty conclusive proof that it wasn't finished at the time of The Incident.

[mastyrwerk]

Originally Posted by ThisIsMyDestiny

ah i bought the boxset last week, it's already on the shelves in England

i watched He's Our You last night, and when Oldham gives Sayid the truth serum he names The Swan as one of their stations, to which Radzinsky replies ''how can he know what we were gonna call it? we haven't even built it yet!'' so that's pretty conclusive proof that it wasn't finished at the time of The Incident.

Mmmm good point. I guess the video was either intentionally misleading as to when the incident happened, or it was a snafu on the continuity dept.

[thrashed2pieces]

Originally Posted by iwoodress

and if its always happened that way, doesn't that point to the fact that blowing up the hydrogen bomb didn't actually do anything BUT cause "the incident" that messed up Chang's hand?

OK... well I've got my own theory on this. Dr. Chang definitely survives to make the Swan video with a brand new hand... the injuries looked like they crushed the bones inside, there's not much coming back from that. I think the H-bomb possibly DESTABILIZED that pocket of energy rather than destroy it, setting the events into motion that will eventually crash the plane and effectively place the losties in a purgatorial loop. I know Farraday was smart and all, but you can't ignore the way the writers of the show had Miles subtlely allude to that possibility. I'm going with "whatever happened, happened", and I think it was Jacob's plan all along in order to keep something much worse from happening. I think S6 will be them being dislodged from this "loop of fate" somehow by the "nemesis". That's my wild theory lol

[Carouselambra]

i saw a deleted scene when his arm got crushed he shouted this really fast AHMANMYPENISBROKEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! presumably because it was in his pocket

[sigfrik]

dude, that is a real answer!!!! LOL

hey., I wanted to add my humble thought: are we SURE he filmed all videos in ONE day??????

cos he might've filmed some before losing his arm, some after it in a current single one timeline.......
And Miles might've not necessarily done anything to safe his life, do we know he did so? he might be there because of the dead people issue....